How scores work

Every rating on this site is a number from 1 to 10. Here is what each number means and where the ratings come from.

What the numbers mean

The same scale for every category and every piece of gear, whoever gives the rating.

10OutstandingAs good as it gets.
9ExcellentAmong the best in its class.
8GreatA clear strength of this gear.
7GoodBetter than most, little to complain about.
6DecentDoes the job, a touch better than average.
5OkayAverage. Neither a strength nor a weakness.
4Below parA weakness you notice now and then.
3WeakA weakness you would have to live with.
2PoorGets in the way of riding.
1AvoidSpoils the gear.

What 1 and 10 mean in each category

Each category has its own two ends.

Category101
Overall ratingOutstandingAvoid
Low-end powerPowers up in barely anyNeeds plenty of wind
High-end controlRock solidHandful in gusts
Depower rangeTotalMinimal
Upwind abilityClimbs upwind easilySlips downwind
Bar feedbackDirect and preciseNumb and vague
RelaunchEffortlessA struggle
DriftDrifts foreverFalls out of the sky
BoostSends you skywardStays low
HangtimeFloats foreverDrops you fast
KiteloopsSmooth and controlledVicious / unpredictable
DurabilityBombproofFalling apart

Some things, like bar pressure and turning speed, have no better end. Riders report them, but they are never averaged or ranked.

Where ratings come from

Each review says which of three kinds it is. All three go into one shared average for the gear, and each review counts once.

Rider

Riders of this site

Someone who flies the gear, scoring it from their own sessions.

Manufacturer

The brand's own rating

Taken from the figures the brand publishes. The maker's view of its own gear, until riders weigh in.

Press review

Based on a published test

A magazine, website or video review, turned into scores by the rules below and linked to the original.

As riders weigh in, the brand's rating and the press reviews become a smaller share of the average. Ride any of this gear? Rate it and help make the numbers the riders' own.

How the brand's rating is made

Many brands show their own charts on a product page: bars or dots for each riding style, and sometimes for handling, like hangtime or kiteloops. We take those charts from the brand's own website and put them on our scale.

  • Their scale onto ours. A chart out of 5 is doubled, a percentage is divided by ten, a chart out of 10 is taken as it is.
  • Only what the brand shows. A category the brand doesn't rate stays empty. We never guess it from the name or the marketing text.
  • No overall score. Brands don't give their own gear a verdict, so the brand's rating has none.
  • Every size at once. A brand rates the model, not one size, so its rating names no size.
  • Shown under the brand's name with the Manufacturer label, and the same review form fields as a rider's, so the two can be compared side by side.

How a press review becomes numbers

Magazines and testers mostly write; this site counts. We read the review, find what it says about each category, and match its words to the scale.

ScoreWording in the review
10
10/105 of 5 starsOnly from the review's own top mark, never from wording.
9
excellentexceptionaleffortlessclass-leadingone of the best we've tested
8
greatvery goodimpressivea real strength
7
goodwellquickconfident
6
decentsoliddoes the jobno complaints
5
okayaveragefinetypical for its classnothing special
4
below parcould be bettertakes some efforta bit slownot its strong point
3
weaksluggishstrugglesnoticeably behind
2
poorhard workfrustratinga real problem
1
avoidvery poorunusabledangerous

Each word belongs to one score only. A review that gives its own numbers is converted to our scale directly, and the review shows the sum. The list grows as we read more reviews.

  • Only what the review talks about. A category the review doesn't mention stays empty. We never fill a gap with a guess.
  • The tester's experience, not the brand's claims. A review that repeats the maker's material list says nothing about durability, so it is not scored from that.
  • The overall score is the review's own verdict when it gives one. Otherwise it is the average of the categories we could score.
  • In our own words. The write-up is a short summary, never the original text, with a link to the full review and its date.
  • One review per source. A test is never used twice.

An example

“It relaunches effortlessly, even in light wind, and drifts well on the wave. Upwind it does the job, but it's not the quickest turner in this group.”
Relaunch9
Drift7
Upwind ability6
Low-end power, boost, durability …empty

“Turning speed” is not scored: neither end is better.

Something here doesn't match a review you see on the site? Tell us.